Ethernet Direct vs. Hirschmann
SPECIAL NOTE:
Caution ! Some Manufacturers list their products as managed switches because they can respond to a limited number SNMP requests or can be configured from a webpage.
Managed Switches in the commercial world support SNMP v1, v2, or v3 in addition to RFC 1493 and can be monitored by open network management packages and not the vendor specific software. IntraVUE is the open standard for Industrial Ethernet network management applications and works with vendors who support true management of their switches.
For a more detailed ED vs. Hirschmann product specification comparison (click here)
Compare a 5 port unmanaged switch, 5 TX ( copper ports )
| Ethernet Direct HUE-500S |
Hirschmann Spider 5TX |
|
| Price | $99 |
$150 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| Dual power inputs | yes |
no |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
Compare an 8 port managed switch, 6 TX ( copper ports), 2 FX ( multimode ports), SC connectors
| Ethernet Direct HME-621 |
Hirschmann RS20-0800M2M2SDAE ( RS2-FX/FX ) |
|
| Price | $795 |
$1,680 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
Compare an 8 port managed switch, 8 TX ( copper ports)
| Ethernet Direct HME-800 |
Hirschmann RS20-0800T1T1SDAE (RS2-TX/TX) |
|
| Price | $595 |
$1,395 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
Compare an 8 port managed switch, 6 TX ( copper ports ), 2 FX ( singlemode ports), SC connectors
| Ethernet Direct HME-623 |
Hirschmann RS20-800S2S2SDAE |
|
| Price | $1,050 |
$2,055 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
Compare an 18 port managed switch, 16 TX ( 10/100 copper ports), 2 ( SFP - gigabit )
| Ethernet Direct HMG-1628 |
Hirschmann RS30-1602O6O6SDAE |
|
| Price | $1,650 |
$2,820 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
| Use any brand of SFPs | yes |
no |
Compare a 10 port managed switch, 8 TX ( 10/100 copper ports), 2 ( SFP - gigabit )
| Ethernet Direct HMG-828 |
Hirschmann RS30-0802O6O6SDAE |
|
| Price | $1,495 |
$1,875 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
| Use any brand of SFPs | yes |
no |
Compare an 8 port managed switch, 6 TX ( 10/100/1000 copper ports ), 2 ( 1000TX or SFP - gigabit )
| Ethernet Direct HMG-628G |
Hirschmann RS30-0802T1T1SDAP |
|
| Price | $1,295 |
$2,025 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| SNMP management - v1, v2 or v3 | yes | yes |
| Intravue compatible | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
| Use any brand of SFPs | yes |
no |
Compare an 8 port unmanaged switch, 8 TX ( copper ports )
| Ethernet Direct HUE-800S |
Hirschmann RS2-TX |
|
| Price | $152 |
$485 |
| Case | aluminum |
plastic |
| Warranty | 5 years |
2 years |
| Dual power inputs | yes | yes |
| DIN rail mount | yes | yes |
| Panel mount | yes |
no |
| Temperature rating | -10 C to 70 C |
0 C to 60 C |
*Competition features and prices according to latest information available from a Hirschmann distributor website effective May 5, 2008
*Competitive prices are based on USA pricing, the competitors' prices may be higher or lower depending upon your location. Purchasing from the Ethernet Direct website is at the listed prices, however, shipping to other countries outside North America may incur additional shipping and import duties. Competitive pricing provided for relative comparisons.
Product names mentioned herein are for identification purposes only and may be trademarks and/or registered trademarks of their respective company.